← Back to InsightsBlog6 Min Read

How to Choose a GEO Agency: A Checklist to Apply This Week

· SEO - GEO Expertसमीक्षक: Mark Neary · SEO - GEO Expert
Share

How to choose a GEO agency is a question that usually starts with a meeting calendar and ends with a stack of slide decks. A good choice, however, depends on a few documents you should hold before you talk to any agency: your brand's current position in AI answers, the real questions your customers ask, and a written definition of what success looks like. This article is a practical checklist you can finish in five working days this week. For each day you will find what to do, what to ask and what you should have in hand at the end.

Monday: Record where you stand today

The step most often skipped in agency selection is the baseline. Without a starting point, nobody can prove what changed six months later.

  • Write your brand name, product category and two or three competitors on one page.
  • Prepare a simple table with separate columns for ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews.
  • For each engine, note four things: is the brand mentioned, is it recommended, is your site cited as a source, and is the brand described correctly.
  • Save a dated screenshot of every answer where you see incorrect information.

Output of the day: a dated baseline table. Do not send it to agencies yet. Ask for their own measurement first and compare it with yours.

Tuesday: List the questions customers actually ask

The unit of measurement in GEO work is the prompt, not the keyword. That makes a question list the clearest way to tell an agency what you want.

  • Collect the questions your sales and support teams heard most often over the last three months.
  • Split them into three groups: category questions (which tool is best), comparison questions (A or B) and problem questions (how do I solve this).
  • Write at least five per group, twenty to thirty questions in total.
  • Put Turkish and, where needed, English versions on separate rows.

Output of the day: a shared prompt list that every agency will be evaluated against. With it, each agency sits the same exam.

Wednesday: Shortlist and first screening questions

Talking to more than three agencies usually slows the decision down. When you build the shortlist, look at the agency's own visibility as well as its pitch.

  • Ask AI assistants about the agency itself. How is a team that sells GEO described by those assistants?
  • Email each agency the following questions and ask for written answers:
    • Which AI engines do you measure, and how often is the measurement repeated?
    • What criterion do you use to count an answer as "visible"?
    • Does your report show mention, recommendation, citation and accuracy separately?
    • What do you do in the first thirty days?
  • Note answers that are vague or that only promise "guaranteed rankings". AI answers vary, so guarantee language is a warning sign.

Output of the day: up to three agencies that sent written answers.

Thursday: Sample report and trial measurement

An agency's real quality shows in its report, not in its proposal. Asking to see a report before signing is a reasonable request.

  • Ask each agency for a sample monthly report with the client name removed.
  • Pick five questions from Tuesday's list and ask the agencies for a quick trial measurement on them.
  • Compare the results with your Monday table. If the gaps are large, ask about the method.
  • Look for three things in the report: which prompt was asked in which engine, what the result was, and which piece of work is proposed to fix it.

If a report contains only charts and a general score, it becomes hard to discuss in monthly meetings what changed and why. A report without prompt-level detail does not let you track progress.

Friday: Score the proposals and check the contract

Use a simple scorecard to put proposals side by side. Score each criterion from one to five.

CriterionWhat to look for
Measurement scopeAll five engines and your prompt list
Report detailPrompt-level results and proposed work
Content and technical workA list of concrete changes to your site
Off-site workA plan for directories, comparison sites and review platforms
TransparencyTools and method stated clearly in writing
Exit termsYou can leave with a reasonable notice period

Make sure the contract includes the following:

  • The prompt list and engines to be measured, attached as an appendix.
  • A defined reporting frequency and report format.
  • Ownership of produced content and data stays with you.
  • A mid-point review meeting scheduled at the end of month three.

Warning signs to watch for in meetings

Alongside the scorecard, the sentences you hear in meetings help you decide. If you run into any of the situations below, ask a follow-up question and request the answer in writing:

  • The agency does not say which prompts it will measure, or says it will set the list itself without showing it to you.
  • The sample report contains only one overall score, with no split by engine or question.
  • Content production is offered, but there is no mention of fixing wrong or missing information on your existing pages.
  • The contract term is long, but no mid-point review or exit clause is defined.
  • The agency claims a special agreement or privileged access to AI engines.

None of these signs has to be a reason to drop an agency on its own, but each is a point that needs to be clarified.

The first two weeks after you choose

Control should stay with you after you sign. Within the first two weeks, ask the agency for an action plan and map it to your baseline table. Ask which prompt, which engine and which metric each action is expected to affect. If that mapping is missing, it becomes hard to connect the work to the results.

Comparing the agency's reports with an independent measurement is also a good habit. Jumpix AI Visibility asks the questions customers ask to ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews; it measures whether the brand is mentioned, recommended, cited and described correctly, then lists what to fix. It costs 9.90 USD a month for one brand, and you can run a free check without signing up. You can see how the measurement works on the GEO service page.

For the full picture of agency types, pricing models and long-term evaluation criteria, read the buying guide for choosing a GEO agency. This checklist is the practical companion to that guide.

How to choose a GEO agency: the week at a glance

  • Monday: baseline table
  • Tuesday: shared prompt list
  • Wednesday: a three-agency shortlist with written answers
  • Thursday: sample report and trial measurement
  • Friday: scorecard and contract check

With these five outputs in hand, you lead the conversation whichever agency you work with.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to run my own measurement before hiring a GEO agency?

It is not mandatory, but it helps a lot. With your own baseline you can verify the agency's reports and see progress independently.

Can a GEO agency guarantee the top spot in AI answers?

No. AI answers change by question, engine and time. A reliable agency offers measurable goals and regular reporting instead of guarantees.

How many prompts are enough to evaluate an agency?

Twenty to thirty well-chosen questions are enough for most brands at the start. What matters is that the questions come from real customers and are spread evenly across the three groups.

Try it with your own leads.

Start on the free plan; no credit card needed.

Free plan, no credit cardSet up in minutesCancel anytime