← Back to InsightsBlog6 Min Read

Questions to Ask Before Hiring a GEO Agency: A One-Week Plan

· SEO - GEO ExpertReviewed by Mark Neary · SEO - GEO Expert
Share

Finding a list of questions to ask before hiring a GEO agency is easy; the hard part is turning those questions into a real decision process. You only see the difference between a presentation that looks good in a meeting and a team that will actually move your business forward when you compare the answers against the same criteria. This article gives you a step-by-step selection plan you can apply within one week.

If you want to see in detail which questions matter and why, read our B2B guide to questions for GEO agencies. Here we focus on how to ask those questions, how to score the answers and how to make the decision.

Day 1: Take your own baseline measurement

Before you talk to any agency, you need to know where you stand today. Otherwise, six months from now you will answer "did anything improve?" only by looking at the agency's own report.

  • Write down 15-20 real questions your customers ask AI assistants.
  • Ask these questions in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews.
  • For each answer, note whether your brand is mentioned, recommended, cited as a source and described correctly.
  • Save the results as a dated file.

This file is the strongest tool you have in agency conversations. You can compare the agency's analysis with your own measurement and spot exaggerated or vague claims immediately.

Day 2: Write down goals and boundaries

If you do not give every agency the same brief, you cannot compare their answers. Prepare a one-page brief:

  • Business goal: What does AI visibility serve for you? More quote requests, getting into recommendation lists in a specific category, or correcting wrong information?
  • Priority questions: State clearly the 5-10 questions you want to appear in.
  • Your resources: Who can write content? Who has permission to change the website?
  • Budget range and timeline: You do not need an exact figure, but a range makes proposals realistic.
  • Red lines: For example, state up front that you do not want fake reviews, misleading content or unauthorized posting in your brand's name.

Day 3: Put the questions to ask before hiring a GEO agency into a written form

A shortlist of 3-4 agencies is enough. More makes comparison harder. Email each agency the same brief and the same question form. Asking for written answers matters: what is said in meetings gets forgotten, while written answers can be compared.

The form should cover at least these points:

  1. How do you take the baseline measurement, in which tools and with how many questions?
  2. Which metrics do you report and how often do you share the report?
  3. What exactly do you deliver in the first 30 days?
  4. Which changes do you recommend on our site, and who will implement them?
  5. How do you approach external sources such as directories, comparison lists and industry publications?
  6. What do you do when AI describes our brand incorrectly?
  7. What happens if there are no results, and what are the exit terms of the contract?

Day 4: Enter the answers into a scoring sheet

When the answers arrive, move them all into one sheet. Give each question a simple score from 0 to 2:

  • 0: No answer, or generic phrases ("we use best practices").
  • 1: The method is described but the measurement or the deliverable is vague.
  • 2: A concrete method, a measurable metric and a clear delivery date.

Next to the scores, add an "evidence" column. Did the agency share a sample report, a sample analysis or an anonymized client case? A 1 with evidence is often worth more than a 2 without it.

Day 5: Mark the red flags

Open a separate "caution" column in the scoring sheet. Mark it whenever you see one of the following:

  • Guaranteed rankings: No one can guarantee that AI will recommend you in a specific position. Answers vary.
  • A quote without measurement: An agency that gives a package price without looking at your current state is not building a plan for your business.
  • Vague reports: Reports that say "your visibility increased" without showing in which questions and which tools.
  • Content production only: Proposals that promise a fixed number of articles per month but never address sources, accuracy or technical access.
  • Mass, automated content: Proposals to produce hundreds of low-quality pages can harm your brand over time.

Day 6: Call references and ask for a trial analysis

Ask the two highest-scoring agencies for references and call at least one of them. Ask the reference three questions:

  • What exactly was delivered in the first month?
  • Did the reports match your own measurement?
  • How did the agency behave when a problem came up?

Then ask both agencies for a short trial analysis of 3 questions where you scored weakly in your baseline. Whether this is paid or free depends on the agency, but it is the best way to see their approach. Compare it with your own measurement: do they see the same problems, and are their recommendations actionable?

Day 7: Start with a pilot and pin down the contract

Starting with a 2-3 month pilot instead of a long contract reduces risk. Make sure the contract states:

  • The baseline measurement and which questions will be measured again
  • Monthly deliverables (page edits, new content, external source work)
  • Report format and frequency
  • An evaluation meeting at the end of the pilot, with terms to continue or exit
  • That ownership of the content and accounts produced stays with you

During the pilot, check the agency's reports regularly against your own independent measurement. Jumpix AI Visibility is built for this: it asks the same questions in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews, measures whether the brand is mentioned, recommended, cited and described correctly, and lists what needs fixing. If you want to combine the measurement with expert support, see how we work on our GEO service page.

After the decision: internal preparation for week one

The work does not end when you pick the agency. To make sure the first week of the pilot is not wasted, prepare the following on your side:

  • Assign one owner. Name one person who answers the agency's questions and manages approvals. Multiple contacts slow decisions down.
  • Grant access up front. Provide access to the site admin panel, Search Console, analytics tools and, if needed, directory profiles on day one.
  • Share the fact card. Give the agency the current page with your brand's correct facts. Corrections to wrong information run through this card.
  • Agree on approval times. Agree in writing how many days you need to approve content and page changes.
  • Fix the first meeting agenda. Put your baseline measurement, the agency's trial analysis and the priority question list on the table in the same meeting.

This preparation keeps the first month of the pilot from being spent waiting for approvals and access.

Frequently asked questions

How many GEO agencies should I talk to?

A shortlist of 3-4 agencies is enough for most businesses. If you send all of them the same brief and the same written question form, you can compare their answers fairly.

Can a GEO agency guarantee results?

Because AI answers vary, guaranteeing a specific ranking is not realistic. Ask instead for measurable deliverables and a commitment to regular, repeatable measurement.

How long should the pilot period be?

Two to three months is a reasonable period to make the first fixes and measure their effect with the same question list. At the end of the pilot, compare with your baseline and decide whether to continue.

Try it with your own leads.

Start on the free plan; no credit card needed.

Free plan, no credit cardSet up in minutesCancel anytime